June 2020 – The personal blog of James Roy II

Literature Review: Part 2 – Influential Urban Planning Literature Lacks Revolutionary Rhetoric

The Most Influential Urban Planning Literature Has Been Indirect in Assuming the Responsibility of Restoring Equity for Black Communities and Sharing the Need to Change the Process

The profession of urban planning has struggled to fully grasp the transgressions of its sins, which is reflected upon diving into the most influential writings of the industry. This may be fueled by white guilt and an inability to empathize with Black and Brown people, as the industry is predominantly white (81%) and male (60%) (Owens). It could also be that the 20 most influential planning books are written by white authors, with only two of the 20 written by women, as ranked by Planetizen, an online planning news website. Furthermore, one of the books in the top 20 is written by Frederick Law Olmstead Jr., the segregationist mentioned earlier (“Top 20 Urban Planning Books (Of All Time)”). In order to truly change the dynamics of this industry, an uncomfortable, yet necessary reckoning must occur. Urban planning has danced around the issues of inequity that it has created, while celebrating the works of the past.

Literature Review: Part 1 – The Overtly Racist Practices of the Urban Planning Industry

The goal of this literature review is to discuss the immensely adverse impacts that urban planning has embedded in Black communities across the United States, while examining the history and current context of the problem, and researching community-led responses.

It’s no secret to the profession that urban planning has had a direct hand in some of the most egregious acts of dividing people to promote inequality. Many books and university programs document the history of segregation, zoning, and government policy and its impacts on poverty and communities of color. Planning scholars and students are now taught to plan equitably, think deeper about creating environments that encourage diversity, and to serve a generally nobler cause.

What hasn’t been explored is how the profession can serve as a restorative practice to the people that it wronged the most. Throughout this review, literature will be analyzed to extract the reasons that practices of the future could and should reach deeper into the intentionality of restoration of the injustices of the past. Through accepting the responsibility of its crimes, understanding the compounding impacts that exist for African Americans today, and providing greater platforms for community-led responses to today’s complexities, the industry of urban planning can be a valuable lever to the reparations that Black communities are owed historically and currently in the United States.

The quest to finish my master thesis…

Draft Sections of James’ Master Thesis in Urban & Regional Planning in Order

I have struggled mentally and questioned reality on a regular basis… Hate is alive and has shined through as an active pandemic ravages the world…

Month: June 2020

Literature Review: Part 2 – Influential Urban Planning Literature Lacks Revolutionary Rhetoric

The Most Influential Urban Planning Literature Has Been Indirect in Assuming the Responsibility of Restoring Equity for Black Communities and Sharing the Need to Change the Process

Literature Review: Part 1 – The Overtly Racist Practices of the Urban Planning Industry

The quest to finish my master thesis…

Draft Sections of James’ Master Thesis in Urban & Regional Planning in Order

Thesis Introduction: Part 1

Thesis Introduction: Part 2

Literature Review: Part 1 – The Overtly Racist Practices of the Urban Planning Industry

Literature Review: Part 2 – Influential Urban Planning Literature Lacks Revolutionary Rhetoric

Literature Review: Part 3 – Black Planners are the Bridge to Systemic Change